AI and EdTech
Reducing Pupil-Facing EdTech & AI: Frequently Asked Questions
Our work at Generation Focus is informed by hundreds of conversations with school leaders, teachers and parents. We listen to their concerns and ground our work in their day-to-day realities. These FAQs are based on the most frequent topics that come up in our discussions.
01
We need to develop pupils’ digital literacy to succeed in the modern world.
School leaders consistently say they feel under pressure from parents to use digital technology. Parents are understandably anxious for their children to have the right skills to get a good job.
It’s undoubtedly true that pupils will need digital literacy and skills to succeed in an increasingly digital world. But time on screens does not necessarily lead to either.
You don’t become a master brewer by drinking lots of beer.
International assessments of pupils’ digital literacy show that despite increasing exposure to technology in and out of school, today’s teenagers score lower on basic digital problem-solving tasks than pupils did a decade ago (ICILS 2023).
There is also growing consensus that Millennials have better workplace digital skills than GenZ (Pfaltzgraf , D. ., & Insch, G. S. (2021)) with employers lamenting that graduates lack the digital and problem-solving skills required for effective computational thinking. (https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6ad743409bea51d58eac1893/professional-business-services-jobs-plan.pdf)
Convenience, at what cost?
Technology is getting easier to use. Keyboard skills have been replaced with predictive text, learning to organise and save files is redundant with autosave and search features. Even basic Google research is short-circuited by AI summaries. Technology’s greatest leverage over modern life is its convenience, but we must consider the cost for pupils in respect of their digital literacy skills, and indeed all the other skills that underpin digital literacy – critical thinking, communication, problem solving.
The digital systems and tools children use in the classroom today are very different to those used most commonly in the workplace today, let alone those which will be used in the near future but haven’t even been invented yet. Teaching pupils with the tools of the moment doesn’t build the foundation they need to develop the skills they’ll need for the future.
So what do pupils need to build their digital literacy?
Answer: a strong understanding of the world and the core skills that produces.
Cognitive science research tells us that skills are highly topic-specific and, for this reason, they’re less transferrable than we used to think.
For example, football managers need a deep understanding of tactical strategies, their players and the opposition. Hospital managers need to know a lot about clinical governance, patient safety and healthcare workforce pressures. Being a great football manager doesn’t make you a good hospital manager.
In a digital context, subject knowledge makes identifying misinformation possible. You can’t spot what’s wrong if you don’t know what’s right in the first place.
02
Our pupils are more engaged when they use technology in their learning.
Pupils spend so much time on screens outside of school using them in classrooms is the only way to engage them. Plus, they are digital natives so learning online makes sense.
To address this concern it’s important to distinguish between behavioural engagement (being busy, logging in, clicking and completing activities) and cognitive engagement (thinking hard, wrestling with ideas, confronting misconceptions and developing a deep understanding of concepts). Just because pupils are engaged with a digital platform or tool, doesn’t mean they are learning.
EdTech companies often use behavioural measures such as time spent on a platform and completion rates to demonstrate engagement. But these tell us very little about whether pupils are actually learning. So, schools need to look beyond how much time pupils are spending using technology and ask whether it’s helping them think more deeply, build knowledge and remember what they have learned.
As Daniel Willingham, a cognitive psychologist, puts it: ‘memory is the residue of thought’: pupils remember what they think about, not simply what they click on and complete.
Another problem is that screens are highly susceptible to hijacking attention because outside of the classroom they are entertainment – they’re designed to be fun machines. The same device we give pupils for learning is also a gateway to games, videos and endless other distractions. Pupils might sit down with the intention of completing one task but quickly find themselves switching between tabs, apps and activities. This kind of multitasking comes at a steep cost: pupils lose time, make more mistakes and struggle to maintain the sustained focus needed for learning.
It’s tempting to think that technology might be able to expedite the process of committing to memory an understanding of the world around us to help us make sense of it in the future. Unfortunately, in many cases technology removes the friction humans need for the learning process to take place in the first place. The promise of EdTech and AI is built around this premise: providing instant answers, removing obstacles, automating the process, all ultimately reducing the need for effort. Humans learn what they think about. Thinking needs to comprise the right amount of cognitive struggle for it to be committed to memory. Ultimately for pupils, we need to resist the temptation to make learning as frictionless as the technology they will come to use in their adult lives.
03
We already teach pupils how to use technology responsibly.
AI and digital platforms are here to stay and it’s our job to teach pupils how to use it responsibly and effectively, rather than restrict its use.
Teaching pupils how to use technology is important, but it’s not enough. We need to be realistic about the environment we are asking them to navigate. AI, for example, is becoming increasingly difficult for pupils to resist. It offers quick, covert convenience. It can complete a task when you’re under time pressure and you’re unlikely to be found out. The problem isn’t necessarily one big decision to cheat or take a shortcut. Rather, it’s the cumulative impact of dozens of small and seemingly insignificant decisions: asking AI to explain a concept, suggesting an answer, improving a paragraph or completing a bit of homework. Each time a little bit of the thinking that should be done by the pupil is outsourced.
We’re also asking pupils to exercise extraordinary levels of self-regulation in an environment deliberately designed to make that difficult. Technology companies employ teams of expert engineers and behavioural scientists to make their products as engaging and habit-forming as possible. Expecting pupils, whose executive functioning skills are still developing, to consistently resist these design features through responsible choices alone is an unfair ask. Teaching responsible technology use matters, but it’s insufficient. The reason increasing numbers of schools are reviewing homework policies and requiring handwritten or screen-free conditions is because they’re realising this is a battle they cannot win. The most sensible thing you can do in a battle you can never win is to change the terms of engagement.
04
Teachers are already stretched and EdTech reduces their workload.
Transferring to alternative delivery methods would be burdensome.
Managing teacher workload is a cornerstone of successful staff recruitment and retention strategies so digital platforms specifically designed to reduce workload should absolutely be explored. However, we need to be careful about assuming that EdTech automatically does this because we simply don’t know enough about its overall impact on the time teachers spend working.
Many companies sell their products into schools on the promise of saving teachers time but these narrow claims rarely consider the problem in the round. Questions that remain unanswered include whether a product removes the work or simply changes it; what new tasks arise through using the product (managing accounts, monitoring dashboards, troubleshooting problems, logging in) and, most importantly, what new expectations creep in once a new technology is introduced. For example, is time saved on a personalised learning app replaced with higher expectations for generating more data and feedback? Even if EdTech is independently proven to reduce teacher workload, those benefits must be weighed against any impact on pupils’ learning, with the quality of education remaining central to decisions.
05
We’ve already invested heavily in technology.
We have spent thousands on devices and digital infrastructure and promoted it heavily as a “selling point” of our school. There’s no going back now….
This is an example of the sunk cost fallacy: continuing to put time and resources into something because it’s already happened rather than shaping future decisions on new evidence that suggests a different approach might be better. We wouldn’t keep prescribing a treatment simply because we’d invested in its development if new evidence suggested it didn’t work. Our responsibility is to make the best decisions for pupils based on what we know now, not to defend decisions made in the past, when we had less information.
It’s not as simple as that though. Many schools have invested heavily in positioning themselves as technologically progressive. For example device schemes and digital platforms have featured heavily in prospectuses, open days and conversations with staff. Stepping back might feel like an admission that previous decisions were misguided and school leaders might understandably worry about how parents and the wider community might interpret a change in direction. The thing is, early enthusiasm for pupil-facing EdTech was driven by a desire to improve outcomes for pupils and it reflected a wider optimism about technology’s capacity to solve problems across society. We can draw parallels with social media: not long ago we welcomed the opportunities it offered for children to connect with others and explore their interests, but as our understanding of the harms has grown, we’ve rethought that enthusiasm and put greater safeguards in place. Recent research on EdTech and AI tells us we need to take that more critical stance now. Money has already been spent, so the question now is whether continued investment (of money, time and pupils’ attention) stacks up against the concerns the evidence brings to light.
06
Technology helps pupils with SEND.
EdTech platforms allow children to move at their own pace, so children with SEND don’t get left behind. It helps my child bypass cognitive and physical barriers.
Pupils who are neurodivergent (e.g. autistic or those with ADHD) and those with Special Educational Needs (e.g. speech and language or learning difficulties) are more vulnerable to the harms of excessive screentime and have fewer resources to resist it, so it is particularly important to consider their use of technology in schools.
Not all EdTech to support pupils with SEND is equal. Assistive technologies, such as speech-to-text software, can be transformative in removing barriers and making learning more accessible for some pupils.
By contrast, pupils with SEND are more vulnerable to the addictiveness of EdTech designed to provide constant stimulation and compulsive engagement. These apps and platforms can temporarily distract pupils from their overwhelming bodily sensations and emotions, but they do not support a pupil’s ongoing learning of how to cope with stress, emotional discomfort or the necessary friction of learning. EdTech presents a real opportunity cost here, reducing opportunities for repeated, real-world experiences, face-to-face communication and connection that actually support their development and learning..
Health Professionals for Safer Screens have excellent guidance on assistive technology, emotional development and supporting children with SEN and on screentime for children with SEN in primary school.
07
Gamified platforms are the only way some pupils will do their homework.
Some use of gamified platforms to practice times tables or spelling is surely better than no practice of times tables.
Leaderboards, streaks and rewards are all types of engagement features that gamify learning. Teachers use them judiciously to drive learning. When commercial EdTech companies use them, they’re optimised to drive time on the product because user engagement is a key indicator of commercial success and investor confidence. Digital gamification typically shifts the control of engagement from teachers to the platform itself. Digital environments often amplify gamification well beyond what we would consider healthy in an analogue setting.
Some EdTech companies take user engagement a step further and employ manipulative design features straight out of the social media playbook, for example mimicking Snapchat streaks and push notifications.
Home versus school
For a variety of reasons, many parents are unable to support and supervise their children to do homework. In those circumstances it may be beneficial for a child to spend a limited amount of time on a gamified learning platform. If it reduces the amount of time they spend on non-learning platforms – Roblox, social media, YouTube – then there is no opportunity cost – in fact this may represent a more positive use of time.
However, we need to question whether it is appropriate for children to be using gamified, maximally engaging digital apps, when they are at school where support and supervision is available and the opportunity cost is much higher.
As awareness about the harms of excessive screen time increases, there is a growing appetite among parents to restrict digital devices at home. Online homework, with no analogue alternative, can therefore be a source of tension between parents, children and school, especially if pupils are rewarded for time spent on EdTech platforms.
AI and EdTech
More in this section
Facing a question we have not covered?
Tell us and we will help you answer it.

